Featured Reviews

Hit-Monkey
-->
Editor rating
 
3.9
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Daytripper #3
-->
Editor rating
 
2.6
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Dark X-Men #4
-->
Editor rating
 
3.5
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Human Target #1
-->
Editor rating
 
2.6
User rating
 
0.0 (0)

Ultimate X #1 Hot

 
Ultimate X #1
Editor rating
 
1.5 User rating
 
2.6 (2)
Written by Jeph Loeb
Art by Arthur Adams
Lettered by Albert DeschesneRichard Starkings

Yet another Ultimate book begins! Will this be as good as the last? Read on to find out.

Fuck you, Jeph Loeb.

I don't know any other fucking way to say it. That's all this is. There were be more words, because I have a quota to fill, but they will all boil down to this. What is this? I'm sitting here and not knowing what use to words to express my hate.

Hatred is too fucking tame a word, Jeph.

Too. Fucking. Tame.

Y'see, I like the X-Men. I like them rather a lot. They brought me into comics. I have a whole chunk of the Claremont issues. I have games. I have novels. I wouldn't even be surprised if I still had action figures somewhere. I have read every single issue ever written about them.

Yeah, that's not hyperbole. I'm not exaggerating. No 'except ____' or 'starting from ____'.

Every. Single. One.

Y'know, when it was other things you were fucking with, like fucking Supreme fucking Power, or the Hulk, I could take it. Captain America? I could take it. I could, really. I'd whine, I'd bitch, I'd moan, but I can take it. But this? No. Now you've started pissing in my playground.

Now it's personal.

I don't even know how to express what this is. I'm normally pretty eloquent, but this just isn't cutting it. Whatever feelings you're picking up from these words on this page pales in comparison to my rage. I could actually talk about the issue. I could say that this is Way's fansertion clawcest bullshit run through a Loebotomization and shat in technicolor glory onto the page before me. I could say that for everything Ultimate Enemy did to restore my faith in the line, this ruined. I could. But that would demean the purity of my rage. That would belittle the affront this thing is to my eyes and my brain.

And the sad thing is that, as much as I would like to, I can't pin this all on Jeph. It takes more than awful plots worse than most fanfiction thrown together by horny adolescents, dialogue more at home in low-budget soap operas, and the worst characterization this side of Chris Claremont's Psylocke to ruin a book. It also takes thin faces, cheekbones sharp enough to slit a throat, feathered hair, and impossible muscles straight out of Liefeld's handbook, which is where Art Adams comes in as he completely ignores the established character designs for the Ultimate versions of Kitty Pryde and Wolverine, as well as horribly-colored text boxes that form gigantic textwalls of fail so large that they apparently took two letterers to compose.

Just get out, Loeb. Just stop this. I don't know what you think you're doing here. Is it some kind of fucking sadistic glory, to ruin all we hold dear? Is that it? Are you trying to put us through as much pain as you went through? Is this all a gigantic exercise in motherfucking sadism, to see how much mind-numbing bullshit we can take before we explode? Because, you know, if this was all some joke at all the readers' expense, I could almost respect you for it. But I don't think that's the case. I think you actually think this is a good story. That this, that Rulk, that fucking cannibal Blob are what we all want to see. That you have done well by your fans.

Take a fucking reality check. You're a pathetic hack who should have been fired years ago. Give up, bow out, keep hold of some fucking pride and don't you DARE pollute my fucking comics with this bullshit again.

Don't you fucking dare.

If any of you have an ounce of taste, an ounce of intelligence, an ounce of SANITY in you, you will BURN this issue unread.

Don't say I didn't warn you.

Editor review

Fuck you, Jeph Loeb.

Overall rating: 
 
1.5
Art:
 
1.0
Story:
 
2.0
Lettering:
 
1.0
Nick S. Reviewed by Nick S.
February 04, 2010
Top 10 Reviewer
View all my reviews
Report this review
 
Last updated: February 04, 2010
Good Points - It looked pretty when it burned.
Bad Points - I feel like my brain was raped by an old sweaty man in gym shorts with a neckbeard.
 
 


User reviews

Average user rating from: 2 user(s)

To write a review please register or login.
Overall rating: 
 
2.6
Art:
 
4.0   (2)
Story:
 
1.5   (2)
Lettering:
 
1.5   (2)
 
 

Not all that awful... surprisingly

Overall rating: 
 
2.9
Art:
 
4.0
Story:
 
2.0
Lettering:
 
2.0
Good Points - The art.
- Writing wasn't that horrible, seeing as I know Loeb's capable of worse.
Bad Points - Textwalling.
- Weird colours in narrative boxes of sherrif.
 

Art

Overall rating: 
 
2.4
Art:
 
4.0
Story:
 
1.0
Lettering:
 
1.0
 
 
Powered by jReviews
 

Comments  

 
#1 Sully Eliot 2010-02-04 01:01
I love Art Adams, even if he is working with Loeb.
Quote
 
 
#2 Nick S. 2010-02-04 01:16
Art Adams was horribly 90s and completely ignored the look these characters have. Wolverine looked like an old man in a sandstorm, everyone's hair was feathered, the kid is treated like a kid, not like someone with god knows how many muscles, and Kitty Pryde's face and hair do not look like that.
Quote
 
 
#3 Sully Eliot 2010-02-04 01:19
It's not like he's Silvestri or Lee or someone. He's Art Adams, and he's unlike anything I've ever seen and I love his stuff. Especially Monkeyman & O'Brien. In fact, seeing his art on the comic was the only thing that didn't cause me to vomit in my mouth.
Quote
 
 
#4 Nick S. 2010-02-04 01:25
Well, look at Liefeld, or anyone else from the 90s. Then he will not be unlike anything you've ever seen. Then look at Bagley, Immonen, Larroca, recent Adam Kubert stuff, pre-Ultimatum Dave Finch, or anyone else who might have drawn Kitty Pryde or Wolverine in the Ultimate universe, and tell me he isn't Doing It Wrong.
Quote
 
 
#5 Sully Eliot 2010-02-04 01:37
Again, Art Adams looks nothing like anything I've ever seen. Except kinda this one early Dave Finch shot with X-Girls and DC Girls that was awesome. And Bagley can't draw women. I dislike Bagley, even if he can manipulate time.

That said, rereading the issue, Art's art did kinda suck for Art's normal level of quality.
Quote
 
 
#6 Dominik B. 2010-02-04 09:46
I always think Loeb is best - whatever that means these days - when he doesn't have extensive continuity to work with. And here, for some reason, he is allowed to shape continuity, write the foundation of one. And so far, he doesn't do too bad a job.

What I liked about this issue is the revelation that Jimmy's mother is a mutant too. What I didn't like about that is that he just handwaved the whole Adamantium thing away.

However, what bothered me greatly were those damned internal narrative boxes in blue and grey, referring to the sherrif speaking to himself or the reader. I get it that they wanted "Police colours" to reflect his thoughts, but the guy is wearing a khaki uniform. I mean, what the hell? It's just plain confusing. This makes me once more realize that it's the little things that make a comic readable or not.

Quote:
Kitty Pryde's face and hair do not look like that.

Well, given that she's a well-known mutant, I can understand her need for secrecy a bit. And if it's a heavyhanded nod to times gone by in 616, then so be it. I think it's mandatory to do this these days. So, if anything, her not looking like herself is a good thing.

I, for one, will stick with the book... for now.
Quote
 
 
#7 Nick S. 2010-02-04 17:33
Maybe I'm just mad because I came fresh off reading Alpha Flight, but this is a horrible rape of 616 characters for no reason, and Vindicator (the real James Hudson) was already ultimatized in Aron Coleite's pre-Ultimatum UXM arc. And you can't disguise the shape of your face, Dom.
Quote
 
 
#8 Dominik B. 2010-02-04 17:38
You can't change your bones, no. But - especially as a female, depending on your hairdo and the make-up, you look completely different. Even the shape of the face appears to change.

Then again, thinking about it, she could be wearing an image inducer. This would probably be the smartest course of action, given the current situation.

As for James Hudson being in Ultimate twice... I think there's more than one James Hudson in the United states.
Quote
 
 
#9 Nick S. 2010-02-04 17:42
You mean Canada. And not one with a Heather with history with Wolverine. And if she was wearing an image inducer, would she not just look completely different?
Quote
 
 
#10 Dominik B. 2010-02-04 17:45
You have to put the nods to 616 somewhere, my good man. The audience demands them, regardless of them hating every single one of them.

And yes, the Canadian HudsonJim is a different one from the 'gator-'rasslin' HudsonJim in Florida.
Quote
 
 
#11 Nick S. 2010-02-04 17:48
...Wait.

They had a Hudson that wasn't in Canada?

...RAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAAAAAAAAAAAAAA AAGE!
Quote
 
 
#12 Dominik B. 2010-02-04 18:00
It is entirely possible, yes. I mean, a quick glance at Facebook delivers over 500 Jameses Hudsons. And collectively, the USA and Canada have about 350 Million people. Two Jameses Hudsons seem not too unlikely.
Quote
 
 
#13 Nick S. 2010-02-04 19:09
LOEB YOU ARE TAKING AWAY OUR CANADAAAA!!!!!


FRAHGAHRAGHRGAH RAGRAGRHQRGARHA R!
Quote
 

Add comment

Security code
Refresh